In my growing up years I observed how the adults in my life
would get together with friends to have “coffee & Cake” and good conversation.
If these conversations sometimes sounded like arguments, it was because they
were. Sort of. Someone would posit, someone would give their sharp observation,
someone would object.
But these weren’t fights. They were stimulating arguments.
Often, one of the adults would concede they hadn’t thought about all the
ramifications and will reconsider their position. Even when they agreed to
disagree, it was not unusual for the next gathering to bring reconsidered concessions.
My parents and their friends thought folks who got together
to talk about the weather and comment about the nice refreshments were dull and
not worth inviting over again. Inane conversation was not conversation, but
polite banter appropriate for quick passersby. Friends and relations worth
engaging with had real conversations and many times challenged each other.
That was the world I grew up in.
Imagine my surprise to find the norms were different in the
USA and polite company never brought up religion, politics, or anything that
might have a whiff of differences. The ethos of my new country required a major
cultural shift.
Today, many in the USA lament that they can no longer talk
to members of their family or people who they once considered friends. In
truth, I suspect this is because Americans had no training in real
conversations of substance. How to walk away from an exchange that shed light
on different values or perceptions and come back open-hearted to engage again
or even see another’s point of view? This requires training.
A good conversation has lots of doorknobs. It also requires
the interest in twisting the knobs to peek at the other side of the door.
I have recently lost an Israeli friend (at her choosing) over differences, but it stands as an anomaly in my relationships there. Over many years, I
have lost a few American friends for just such. I accept this is a cultural limitation
and, in some ways, also my inability to fully integrate.
I don't want to over-idealize this. I dislike yelling, which was sometimes part of these interesting conversations of my childhood. To this day, I shudder when the volume/decibel goes up. But even loudness did not indicate a future break in relations and calling others by names of historic mega-villains was something I didn't hear back then.
I was born a dual citizen and have lived all of my adult
life in the USA. But we’re always from where we grew up, aren’t we? I cherish
the Israeli me and the training it gave me.






















.jpg)



